Friday, March 12, 2010
Tim Tebow - Will he be successful quarterback in the NFL?
Counterpoint: Steve Young, the Hall Of Fame quarterback? I think his career will more closely resemble that of Rex Grossman.
P: Rex Grossman? Are you kidding me?
CP: He's a great leader. Unfortunately, his physical skill set won't get it done at the next level.
P: You know, scouts and NFL "experts" say that Tebow won't be a great quarterback because of his arm strength. I just don't buy that.
CP: Have you seen him throw?
P: Of course, but there is nothing wrong with his arm strength at all. He just needs to work on his release. This guy works as hard as anyone and will get that part of his game straightened out.
CP: Changing his release point doesn't fix all the issues he has. David Carr also fixed his release point prior to the draft. How did his NFL career work out?
P: Carr was drafted number one by the Texans. In any case, he will be much better than David Carr.
CP: Another number one pick he compares to is Alex Smith. I could see them having similar careers.
P: Smith, like Carr, is an example of a guy who was rushed. Tebow will need a couple years. Nobody is saying he is NFL ready now.
CP: Tebow also has issues reading defenses and tends to lock into his first option.
P: Whatever...teams will regret passing on this Heisman trophy winner.
CP: Heisman Trophy winners, for the most part, don't have exceptional NFL careers.
P: That means nothing. He is a true leader and would put a fire under his team.
CP: That kind of cheerleader stuff won't work in the NFL.
P: His personality will win over any team.
CP: I disagree. Look, it's hard not to like Tebow. The media seems to love him. He might have an average career as a backup.
P: He throws a very accurate deep ball.
CP: I have seen him connect on some long balls.
P: Tebow is also a proven winner. Most successful NFL quarterbacks have college resumes that look like Tebow's.
CP: Colt McCoy holds the record for most wins by a college QB. Does that mean he will be better than Tebow?
P: No, I like McCoy but not as much as Tebow.
CP: Florida's simplistic offense with Tebow was nothing like any NFL offense.
P: Tebow will devote himself to improving every aspect of his game. He will learn the NFL schemes quickly.
CP: So you are saying he is intelligent?
P: I think he's a very smart and athletic quarterback. One of a quarterback's greatest strengths is their ability to read the defense and execute the plays.
CP: Are you aware that Tebow recorded a 22 on his Wonderlic? That isn't good in case you wondered.
P: Other quarterbacks like Dan Marino, Bret Favre, Donavan McNabb, and Michael Vick scored poorly and went on to fine NFL careers. That test has nothing to do with his football skills, determination, and leadership.
CP: It doesn't help. He doesn't compare to any of those guys anyway.
P: Tebow will be great. He is the greatest college football player ever and he will do great in the NFL.
CP: He may be in the conversation for best college football player ever.
P: He has the Heisman Trophy and two national championships. Nobody in this generation has done that.
CP: I'll give you that. He had a spectacular college football career.
P: Face it, the rare combination of leadership and athletic ability that Tebow has will make him an stud NFL quarterback.
CP: Weren't those same things said of Vince Young?
P: Young will put it all together this season.
CP: Tebow has poor accuracy, doesn't read defenses well, has bad footwork, struggles to take the snap from under center, and has poor mechanics. Tebow is years from being NFL ready as a quarterback.
P: I agree that he will struggle if he doesn't become a pocket passer and tighten up a few other areas.
CP: There isn't a long list of guys that have come into the league with so many areas to work on that have become successful. He works hard. He is a great leader. I get all that.
P: He certainly doesn't have the classic throwing motion.
CP: NFL defensive backs will be licking their chops when he drops back.
P: His greatest asset might be that he makes the people around him better.
CP: That is hard to know. He played for one of the best teams around at Flordia.
P: A good coach will take advantage of Tebow's strengths. He's got the intangibles.
CP: Yeah, I just don't see it.